← All writings

The Anatomy of an Enterprise

admin writings

I approach an enterprise much as I once approached the human body. I observe its organization, investigate its relationships, identify where friction occurs and establish the level at which its various functions have lost their alignment.

I do not consider this a particularly unusual application of osteopathy. What I learned through my investigation of the human body concerns something considerably more fundamental than anatomy: the principles through which intelligence organizes matter in the service of an intent.

The human body comprises an extraordinary number of parts, each possessing particular characteristics and performing particular functions. Yet what confronts us is an organism. Its parts participate in a greater order through which something becomes possible that none of them could accomplish independently.

When I reach for an object, I am not concerned with the innumerable physiological events that make the movement possible. I have an intention. An extraordinary organization of intelligence participates in its manifestation.

The construction of an enterprise involves the same fundamental principle.

The Organization of Intent

An enterprise begins with an intent. Someone wishes to bring something into existence, and an organization gradually develops through which that intention can acquire material expression.

The mission establishes why the enterprise exists. The vision establishes where it is going. From these proceed the decisions concerning its structure, its activities, the people it requires and the resources necessary for its development.

Consider the central nervous system of the human body. It coordinates activities occurring throughout the organism, establishing relationships between functions that might otherwise operate independently. The administration of an enterprise performs a comparable function. Information must circulate, decisions must be communicated, resources must reach the appropriate places, and the consequences of those decisions must become available to the coordinating intelligence.

The significance of this elaborate arrangement lies in its capacity to translate intent into action.

Yet in many enterprises, the original intent becomes increasingly difficult to locate. Departments develop their own concerns, management becomes occupied with management, and employees concern themselves with the particular responsibilities through which they earn their livelihood.

There may be considerable activity. Whether that activity constitutes the coherent expression of an intention is another matter altogether.

A business can be exceptionally busy without being particularly alive.

Sharpening the Blade of Intent

When I begin investigating an enterprise, I am often considerably more interested in its founder’s understanding of what they are attempting to accomplish than in the apparent efficiency of its operations.

If the originating intent lacks clarity, what exactly are we attempting to organize?

Over the years, I have encountered individuals capable of articulating their mission and vision in remarkably sophisticated language. They could describe their objectives, their market and the future they imagined for their enterprise.

Yet there was very little life in what they were expressing.

An intention possesses a certain quality when it arises from something genuinely alive within a human being. There is a tonus to it. It has substance, direction and an organizing power of its own. As the person speaks, the relationships between the various elements of what they are expressing become increasingly intelligible.

One can follow the intention into greater depth without discovering that it is being held together by a collection of unrelated aspirations.

The individual does not need to continually reinforce it. He can breathe within it.

This quality is particularly interesting to observe because a person may speak with tremendous enthusiasm while expressing something that possesses remarkably little vitality. Enthusiasm can be generated through anticipation, imagery and excitement without necessarily proceeding from a genuine intent.

The distinction becomes apparent when one begins to investigate.

A few questions may reveal that the mission consists of borrowed ideas, the vision of borrowed imagery, and the ambition of something the individual feels compelled to prove.

One can construct an elaborate organization around such an intention. One can employ competent individuals, acquire sophisticated infrastructure and refine the efficiency of its operations.

But the organizational apparatus cannot provide the intent with a substance it does not possess.

I have discontinued my involvement with enterprises for precisely this reason. I could perceive where the work needed to begin, but the individuals concerned preferred to remain occupied with the activities of the business rather than undertake the investigation from which those activities ought to proceed.

They wanted to build.

I wanted to establish what we were building, and why.

I sometimes describe this work as sharpening the blade of intent. It involves establishing a more intimate relationship with what one genuinely wishes to accomplish, removing what obscures it and bringing increasing precision to its direction.

This is not an exercise one completes during an afternoon spent drafting a mission statement. The intent needs to be continuously refined as one’s understanding develops and the enterprise acquires substance.

A sharp intent provides an organizing intelligence for everything that proceeds from it. Decisions that would otherwise appear complicated become considerably more intelligible when their relationship to the original purpose can be established.

Vision and Fantasy

There is an important distinction between a man who possesses a vision and one who inhabits a fantasy.

In the course of working with human beings, I have observed how much imaginative activity can arise from an individual’s reluctance to experience what is actually occurring within them.

A man may have difficulty bearing his own desires, anger, appetites or emotional circumstances. He establishes a distance between himself and what he feels. Within that distance, an imaginary existence begins to develop, assembled partly from things he has seen, people he admires and circumstances in which he imagines himself finally becoming someone he could respect.

An enterprise can emerge from such a fantasy.

The individual may believe he wishes to establish an international brand, construct a particular kind of institution or become a prominent figure within his industry. But does he genuinely wish to undertake the work involved in bringing these things into existence? Or is he principally attracted to the person he imagines himself becoming once they exist?

The distinction is often palpable.

A fantasy needs to be sustained. Remove certain flattering elements from the narrative and much of its apparent vitality disappears. Further questions do not necessarily lead to greater depth; they may simply require the invention of additional explanations.

A genuine aspiration, on the other hand, tends to acquire greater substance as one’s relationship with it deepens.

Much of my work in such circumstances consists in helping the individual relax sufficiently to establish contact with what he actually feels. What does he genuinely want? What is he afraid to acknowledge? What would he find worth undertaking if he were no longer concerned with what the undertaking communicated about him?

Sometimes he discovers that the enterprise he has been constructing is fundamentally inappropriate to his aspirations. In other instances, there is something genuine within it, but it has been distorted by his desire to make it into something it is not.

A modest aspiration may have been dressed in an unnecessarily grandiose vision because the individual felt ashamed of its simplicity. Something genuinely beautiful may have been distorted by his conviction that it would not be sufficiently impressive in its original form.

The enterprise has inherited his discomfort with himself.

Once he becomes more at ease with what he actually is, the undertaking can assume a considerably more coherent shape. It no longer needs to fulfil functions that have very little to do with its stated purpose.

A genuine vision does not need to compensate for the man who possesses it.

It can proceed from him.

The Anatomy of Friction

One of the fundamental things osteopathy taught me was not to confuse the location of a symptom with the origin of the disturbance.

A restriction encountered in one part of the body may belong to a much greater organization of relationships. Its significance becomes apparent through understanding what precedes it, what sustains it and what other structures have become involved in accommodating it.

I investigate an enterprise in much the same manner.

Imagine an organization experiencing persistent difficulties within its production department. Deadlines are continually missed, employees appear inefficient and management has become increasingly frustrated.

The obvious response would be to investigate production. Perhaps better equipment is required. Perhaps certain individuals lack competence. Perhaps the department needs to be reorganized.

But production may be attempting to accommodate contradictory instructions from management. Management itself might be responding to commercial commitments incompatible with the organization’s actual capacities. Those commitments may ultimately belong to a founder whose vision of the enterprise bears little relationship to what he has established.

What appears to be a difficulty in production may be the material expression of a confusion occurring several degrees above it.

Replacing the employees will not resolve that confusion. Indeed, they may have developed remarkable ingenuity in compensating for it.

When I encounter friction within an enterprise, I want to understand its anatomy. Where is it expressing itself? What function is being performed? What relationships determine its activities? Are the instructions coherent, the resources appropriate and the responsibilities adequately distributed?

The disturbance may originate in the periphery. There is no reason to search for a profound explanation when a relatively simple one accounts for what is occurring.

But one must possess the faculties necessary to follow the disturbance through the entire organization, including the intelligence through which its direction is established.

Sometimes the administrative apparatus is functioning perfectly well. The difficulty lies in the decisions it has been instructed to execute. At other times, even the decisions are coherent when considered individually, yet they proceed from an intent comprising contradictory aspirations.

An organization may be asked to pursue several incompatible directions simultaneously.

The resulting friction is not necessarily evidence of incompetence within its constituent parts. It may be evidence of the intelligence with which those parts are attempting to accommodate an impossible arrangement.

This is why I am not always particularly interested in discussing a person’s business with them.

Sometimes I am considerably more interested in discussing the person from whom the business proceeds.

The Heart of the Organization

The heart, lungs and liver perform radically different functions. Their contribution to the organism cannot be measured according to a single criterion. Their differences are precisely what make their collaboration possible.

Within an enterprise, however, individuals frequently lose sight of the significance of functions other than their own.

Management may regard those working in production as relatively insignificant. Those in production may regard management as an unnecessary complication. Departments begin protecting their interests, and relationships that ought to be functional become increasingly political.

The abuse of hierarchy can occur in either direction.

Much of this confusion arises when the significance of a position is established independently of what the organization exists to accomplish.

When a genuine intent occupies the heart of an enterprise, its various functions acquire their meaning through their relationship to that intent. Authority exists to facilitate its manifestation, as does the work being performed at every other level.

The position itself is secondary.

Naturally, establishing such coherence becomes increasingly complex as an enterprise grows. Hundreds or thousands of individuals cannot be expected to possess the same intimate relationship with its originating intent as the founder.

I understand why larger enterprises invest considerable intelligence in creating a common ethos. They are attempting to establish something through which their constituent parts can recognize themselves within a greater whole.

In smaller enterprises, where the founder remains intimately involved, these relationships are often more palpable. Something of the intent can be communicated directly, and the consequences of alignment or misalignment become more readily apparent.

But a culture of care cannot be established simply by asking people to care. The organization itself must provide intelligible reasons for doing so. Its various functions must be compatible, its responsibilities appropriately distributed and its relationships conducive to collaboration.

A living intent at the heart of an enterprise is fundamental. It does not, however, absolve us of the responsibility of assembling an organism capable of expressing it.

Harmony and Efficiency

I have often described harmony as the absence of friction.

Within an enterprise, this does not imply the absence of difficulty, disagreement or considerable expenditure of energy. The manifestation of an intent may require enormous effort.

The question is whether the energy being expended participates in that manifestation or is being consumed by compensations within the organization.

An enterprise can expend an extraordinary amount of energy simply maintaining its existing arrangement. Employees compensate for management, management compensates for contradictory decisions, and the founder continually intervenes to resolve difficulties that the structure itself perpetuates.

Everyone works harder. Very little becomes more intelligent.

When the relationships within the enterprise are progressively clarified, activities that previously required considerable intervention may begin to take place with relative ease. Information circulates more freely, responsibilities become intelligible, and decisions no longer need to be endlessly reconsidered because their relationship to the intent has become clearer.

The organization becomes more capable of directing its resources toward what it exists to accomplish.

This is a form of efficiency considerably more interesting to me than simply demanding greater productivity from its constituent parts.

The organism is no longer expending so much of its intelligence compensating for itself.

Work as Devotion

There is another possibility within the construction of an enterprise that interests me considerably more than the accumulation of wealth or the achievement of professional distinction.

It becomes available when the individual establishes a sufficiently genuine relationship with what he wishes to bring into existence.

The work itself can become an art.

I am reminded of a spirit of craftsmanship found within traditional Japanese culture, where the manner in which something is undertaken can possess as much significance as the object ultimately produced. The attention given to each detail, the refinement of one’s faculties and the quality of one’s relationship with the work introduce another dimension to an otherwise ordinary activity.

Work can become a form of prayer.

When an individual develops an enterprise that proceeds from something genuinely alive within him, the daily activities of its construction acquire a different significance. Establishing a relationship with a supplier, refining a product, training an employee or reconsidering the smallest detail of its organization can become expressions of the same aspiration.

Each is an opportunity to give material substance to something he carries within his heart.

The enterprise is no longer merely a vehicle through which he hopes eventually to arrive somewhere more desirable. Its very construction becomes a meaningful part of his existence.

This requires patience.

Something beautiful can be built one step at a time, through a succession of decisions that may appear entirely insignificant to an outside observer. Their significance lies in the intelligence and dedication with which they are undertaken, and in their relationship to the greater undertaking.

Naturally, an enterprise may eventually acquire a life that extends beyond the individual who founded it. Other people enter, circumstances evolve and possibilities emerge that could never have been anticipated at its inception.

Its originating intent may find expression through forms considerably different from those first imagined.

That, too, belongs to its life.

What interests me in working with the founder of an enterprise is the possibility of participating in the construction of something coherent, something whose parts increasingly reflect the intelligence of the whole and whose existence possesses a genuine significance for those undertaking it.

The commercial success of such an enterprise is certainly relevant. Its material viability is part of the intelligence with which it must be constructed.

But there is something else worth accomplishing.

A man can spend thirty years building an enterprise and discover that he has spent thirty years avoiding himself. He can also spend those same years giving increasingly beautiful expression to something he genuinely carries within him.

The outward accomplishments may appear remarkably similar.

The lives through which they were accomplished are entirely different.