← All writings

The Education of the Insensitive

Mikhael K. Shah Essays

As a child, I knew certain things about the adults surrounding me that I would have been entirely incapable of explaining. I could feel the contradictions in their lives, the distance between what they expressed and what was actually taking place within them.

I remember recognizing, at a relatively young age, that much of the way my parents conducted their existence was detrimental to their health. I had no education in the health sciences. I knew nothing about physiology, psychology or the mechanisms through which a particular way of living could affect the human organism.

Nevertheless, something was apparent to me.

Years later, through my studies, I began to understand the nature of what I had perceived.

Much of my education has proceeded in this manner. I feel something, and subsequently undertake the intellectual work necessary to understand it.

This suggests a different conception of education from the one upon which we have largely organized the intellectual development of the human being.

We begin by furnishing the child with information. We introduce him to the world through the observations, discoveries and conclusions of others. We examine his capacity to retain what he has been given and reward his ability to reproduce it.

Yet the child already possesses an instrument through which he encounters reality.

He feels.

And it is this instrument, perhaps more than any other, that deserves to be educated.

The forgotten faculty

A child entering a room in which two adults have just had an argument can often sense that something has occurred. The adults may smile at him, speak pleasantly and present every indication that nothing has happened. The child nevertheless experiences something quite different from what is being presented to him.

He may even be reprimanded for responding to it.

Consider what is taking place here. The child is being asked to disregard his experience of reality in order to accommodate the reality the adults wish to maintain.

He is learning something of considerable usefulness in adult society.

He is learning how not to know.

If this occurs sufficiently often, the child gradually learns to inhabit the world that is explained to him rather than the world he experiences. His intellectual development proceeds alongside a progressive estrangement from his own perceptions.

Something similar happens when a child expresses an interest in a subject that has no place in the curriculum, when his questions interrupt the delivery of a lesson, or when the significance of what he has observed is subordinated to the necessity of providing the expected answer.

He discovers that what interests him and what he is expected to learn are not necessarily related. More importantly, he discovers that his success may depend less upon the quality of his observations than upon his ability to accommodate the expectations of those educating him.

By adulthood, he may possess an impressive education while remaining profoundly uncertain about the most intimate dimensions of his existence.

He struggles to recognize what occurs within himself, what moves through his relationships and whether the life he has constructed corresponds to anything he genuinely desires.

He has learned a great deal about the world.

He has lost intimacy with the faculty through which he encounters it.

The intellect and intelligence

I have always been fascinated by individuals capable of seeing the whole picture.

A man may spend thirty years studying a forest and possess a remarkable quantity of information concerning its vegetation, inhabitants and geological composition. He can describe its individual components with tremendous precision.

Another man rises above the forest. He sees its contours, its relationship with the surrounding terrain, the rivers passing through it and what lies beyond it.

When I encounter someone capable of offering me this second perspective, I become interested.

He provides me with a vision through which the individual elements acquire meaning. I can subsequently descend into the forest and investigate its details with an understanding of where I am and how the things I encounter relate to one another.

This is what I recognize as intelligence.

Analysis separates. Intelligence perceives relationships, synthesizes and recognizes the coherence of the whole. The former is immensely useful when exercised in the service of the latter.

The genuinely intelligent individuals I have encountered have generally possessed an exceptional degree of sensitivity. They are affected by the world. Its contradictions disturb them. There is something within their experience of existence that demands understanding.

Their curiosity is not merely academic.

Understanding is a necessity.

Their investigations rarely remain confined to one discipline because the boundaries separating disciplines are not boundaries that exist within reality itself. The study of one phenomenon continually reveals the necessity of understanding another.

They are pursuing the truth of the matter.

The intellect provides some of the instruments through which that pursuit becomes possible. But an exceptionally developed intellect can also be employed in the avoidance of truth. It can produce sophisticated explanations of things that bear little relationship to reality.

The intelligence of a human being cannot be established merely by examining the sophistication of his instruments.

We must examine what he does with them.

The recognition of truth

Some years ago, while studying financial markets, I encountered an individual whose understanding of economics, currencies and the movement of capital considerably exceeded my own.

There was an enormous quantity of material for me to investigate. Had I proceeded independently, it might have taken me a decade to establish a sufficiently comprehensive understanding of the subject.

What this individual provided me with was perspective.

Through listening to him, I acquired a sense of the entire landscape. I could begin to situate what I was learning and understand its relationship with other things. My studies acquired a direction they had previously lacked.

But what particularly interested me was the familiarity of what he was communicating.

I recognized something I had already sensed.

His vision was clearer than mine. He possessed the intellectual means to articulate what remained indistinct within my own understanding.

There is a particular pleasure associated with such an encounter, quite different from the excitement of acquiring information. Something that had remained obscure becomes visible, and with that visibility comes a certain relaxation.

One recognizes.

Much of my education has consisted in seeking this kind of clarity. I study different sciences, compare observations and seek out individuals whose vision is clearer than mine because there are things I perceive that I wish to understand.

Sometimes the investigation reveals that what I initially sensed was far more complex than I had understood it to be. Sometimes the explanation I had given to my experience proves inadequate.

Feeling that something is wrong and understanding precisely what is wrong are different accomplishments. An error in the interpretation of an experience does not necessarily invalidate the perception that gave rise to it. Nor does the intensity of an experience establish the accuracy of our interpretation.

There is work to be done between the two.

Sensitivity brings something to my attention. The intellect provides the means through which I can investigate its nature.

This, for me, is the beginning of a genuine intellectual life.

Learning how to feel

During my years studying and practicing osteopathy, I was obliged to educate a faculty that had received remarkably little attention throughout my previous education.

I had to learn how to feel.

To place one’s hands upon a living human being and perceive the subtleties of his organism requires something quite different from knowing its anatomy. Anatomical knowledge is indispensable, but it cannot provide the experience of encountering a living body.

For that, one must become sufficiently receptive to what is occurring beneath one’s hands.

I was already a sensitive individual. The difficulty was that I could easily become overwhelmed by what I experienced in the presence of others. I had not developed the internal boundaries necessary to remain established within myself while being receptive to them.

There were two possibilities available to me.

I could diminish my sensitivity and thereby reduce the discomfort associated with it. Or I could develop the stability and precision necessary to remain sensitive without becoming overwhelmed.

The first would have made certain aspects of my existence considerably easier.

The second became an education.

Through years of practice, I learned to remain centered within myself while perceiving another human being. I acquired the means to investigate my impressions, ask questions, refine my understanding and examine the results of my interventions.

The sensitivity that had once overwhelmed me became one of the most useful faculties I possessed.

I sometimes think of this refinement in terms of a radio receiving a transmission. The signal may already be present, but the quality of its reception depends upon the condition of the instrument. Reduce the interference and something previously indistinct becomes remarkably clear.

We have largely confused insensitivity with strength and sensitivity with weakness.

There is an immense difference between a man who remains undisturbed because he perceives very little and a man who remains established within himself despite the magnitude of what he perceives.

Only the latter has refined his instrument.

An intellect without intelligence

In the language of the Indian sciences, sensitivity belongs to the feminine dimension of intelligence. It is receptive. It allows something to become known before the intellect has established what it is.

Through the intellect, what has been received can be investigated, differentiated and given intelligible form.

These two faculties belong together.

One of the fundamental errors of contemporary education is that we have developed elaborate methods for assessing the intellectual accomplishments of a human being without establishing comparable methods for cultivating his receptivity.

We can determine how much information a student has retained, how effectively he can analyze it and how proficiently he can communicate his conclusions. We rarely occupy ourselves with whether his education has made him more perceptive, more intimately acquainted with himself or more capable of recognizing the actual circumstances of his existence.

Yet an intellect deprived of its relationship with perception must obtain its material from elsewhere.

And there is no shortage of people willing to furnish it.

Consider the ease with which an individual can acquire an entire account of a subject without ever having seriously investigated it. He receives information from sources whose authority he has been educated to recognize. He adopts their conclusions, learns their vocabulary and acquires the arguments through which their positions can be defended.

He may become remarkably articulate.

But what has he actually understood?

What makes this situation particularly disturbing is that the development of his intellect may render him less accessible to reality rather than more accessible to it. He now possesses the means to explain away his own experiences, dismiss contradictory observations and construct elaborate arguments in defense of what he has been taught.

His intellect has become the guardian of his conditioning.

And he calls this intelligence.

A population educated in this manner does not require particularly crude forms of coercion. Supply people with an interpretation of reality, establish its intellectual respectability and they can be left to maintain it themselves.

They will reproduce it, defend it, educate their children through it and ridicule those whose observations call it into question.

Their sense of intellectual independence can become one of the principal instruments through which their dependence is maintained.

The problem is not that we rely upon the discoveries of others. No human being could independently verify everything he needs to know. The problem arises when he loses the faculty through which he can establish a living relationship with what he has received.

There is a difference between learning from an authority and allowing an authority to determine the limits of one’s perception.

I have devoted much of my life to studying different sciences precisely because I wish to understand reality more intimately.

But the scientific method presupposes something rather fundamental: a human being sufficiently interested in reality to permit his understanding of it to be disturbed.

The method cannot furnish him with that interest.

Nor can it provide him with the sensitivity to recognize the significance of what he encounters or the courage to pursue an investigation beyond the boundaries of what he would prefer to believe.

These are qualities of the human being conducting the science.

They require an education of their own.

The courage to perceive

There is a reason why so many wisdom traditions have spoken of the necessity of becoming like a child.

I do not understand this as an invitation to abandon the intellectual faculties we have spent our lives developing. It is an invitation to recover something that was unnecessarily sacrificed in their development.

The child has not yet constructed the elaborate intellectual architecture through which the adult protects his version of reality.

The adult has acquired an identity, a position in society, relationships, convictions and romanticized ideas about the nature of his existence. He has invested years, sometimes decades, in their construction.

He has considerable reasons not to feel certain things.

Reality may be devastating to him.

It may reveal something about a relationship he has spent twenty years believing in. It may reveal something about the profession through which he has established his identity. It may reveal that much of what he has understood about himself was never particularly accurate.

His resistance to seeing is not necessarily intellectual.

It is existential.

The dissolution of a cherished understanding can be a profoundly painful experience. The human being must possess sufficient internal resilience to accommodate what he discovers without immediately attempting to protect himself from it.

An intellect can be brilliant and the human being exercising it extraordinarily fragile. Under these circumstances, his brilliance may be employed in preserving the very illusions from which he suffers.

To recover the sensitivity of the child while possessing the intellectual faculties of the adult means remaining available to a reality that has no obligation to accommodate one’s understanding of it.

This is why I cannot separate the cultivation of intelligence from the cultivation of health.

The capacity to see is intimately related to the capacity to bear what one sees.

Where education ought to begin

If I were responsible for the education of a child, the first thing I would teach him would be how to feel himself.

Through meditation and the practices of Yoga, I would want him to become intimately acquainted with his own organism, recognize the movements occurring within him, discover the nature of his constitution and become familiar with the deeper aspirations seeking expression through his existence.

Before attempting to explain the world to him, I would want him to become acquainted with the instrument through which he encounters it.

How is he to understand another human being if he cannot distinguish the movements occurring within himself from those he encounters in another?

From there, his education could proceed in countless directions, according to his constitution and interests.

An education in any art or science acquires a different character when it originates in perception.

In martial arts, for example, there is an immense difference between reproducing a movement one has been shown and perceiving the movement from within.

A technique that appears perfectly executed in isolation may become entirely ineffective in the presence of another human being. Its application requires sensitivity to distance, timing, resistance and movements that cannot be anticipated in their entirety.

Once the student begins to perceive these relationships, the technique ceases to be something he merely reproduces. He understands why it works. He can adapt it, refine it and discover possibilities that the original instruction did not contain.

The teacher remains immensely valuable. But what he communicates now enters into a living relationship with the experience of the student.

This principle extends well beyond martial arts.

The education of a human being should progressively diminish the distance between learning and discovery. What he receives from others should develop his capacity to encounter something for himself, not render such an encounter unnecessary.

The greater his intellectual faculties become, the more intimate his relationship with reality ought to become.

Otherwise, what have those faculties accomplished?

I have no desire to produce human beings who think as I do. There are dimensions of reality that another human being, by virtue of his particular constitution, may become capable of perceiving far more clearly than I ever will.

The purpose of educating him is not to populate his mind with my discoveries. It is to develop within him the faculties through which he may make discoveries that were never available to me.

And perhaps, one day, he will allow me to see something.

We have become enormously concerned with what we put into the mind of a human being.

I would be considerably more concerned with the condition of the human being into whose mind we are putting it.

For the accomplishment of education is not an individual who knows what others have discovered.

It is an individual through whom reality can continue to be discovered.