← All writings

The Art of Being and Becoming

Mikhael K. Shah Essays

My interest in business has never been exclusively entrepreneurial. I have created businesses and participated in the development of enterprises, but these activities have always belonged to a greater undertaking: the discovery of what a human being is and the development of the faculties through which that nature finds expression in the world.

I cannot separate the development of an individual from the development of what genuinely proceeds from that individual. Both interest me, and much of my work concerns the relationship between them.

It is the relationship between being and becoming.

Two Sides of the Same Coin

Consider a seed. Within that seemingly insignificant object resides the possibility of an extraordinary organism. It possesses a particular nature, and through its relationship with the environment, that nature gradually acquires expression. Roots develop, branches extend, leaves appear, and eventually the tree bears fruit.

What it becomes is an expression of what it is.

There are two fundamental movements within the development of a human being. One concerns discovering who and what we are, understanding our nature and establishing a harmonious relationship with ourselves and with life. I refer to this as self-realization.

The other concerns developing the faculties through which our nature can acquire expression and contribute something of value to the world. This is self-actualization.

In the traditional language of the feminine and masculine principles, the feminine movement is inward and the masculine movement is outward. One concerns the discovery of one’s nature; the other concerns its manifestation. Like Yin and Yang, these are complementary movements within the same human being, irrespective of sex.

I cannot conceive of self-realization independently of self-actualization. The distinction allows us to understand their respective functions, but their development is inseparable. As we discover ourselves, something seeks expression. Through that expression, we discover something further about ourselves.

The seed cannot reveal the entirety of its nature independently of becoming a tree.

Discovering Ourselves Through Living

There is a tendency in certain spiritual environments to concern oneself almost exclusively with the inward movement. One meditates, investigates one’s thoughts, observes one’s emotions and gradually develops an understanding of oneself. These are valuable undertakings, but there are aspects of ourselves that will remain inaccessible until we participate more fully in life.

How does one discover the nature of one’s generosity without encountering circumstances in which generosity can find expression? How does one understand one’s creative faculties without creating? How does one discover the quality of one’s discernment, patience or capacity to assume responsibility without entering relationships and undertakings that require them?

There are things about ourselves that we cannot discover independently of the circumstances through which they become operative.

A person may spend years investigating himself and acquire considerable inner understanding. Yet when he enters an intimate relationship, assumes responsibility for others or attempts to bring something into existence, entire dimensions of himself become available for investigation that were previously inaccessible to him.

His self-realization has not ended. It has entered another territory.

This is where the relationship between the feminine and masculine movements becomes particularly interesting. Something discovered inwardly seeks outward expression, and the experience acquired through that expression returns the individual to himself with a greater understanding of his nature.

Each movement enriches the other.

It is not sufficient to know something of who we are while leaving the possibilities inherent in our nature undeveloped. Until those possibilities acquire expression, much of what we are remains unknown to us.

Being has its activity.

A Culture of Accomplishment

The opposite phenomenon is perhaps even more familiar. An individual becomes extraordinarily active in the world without establishing much of a relationship with himself. He develops numerous skills, acquires knowledge, establishes relationships and perhaps builds an impressive enterprise.

But what exactly is being expressed through all this activity?

Much of contemporary entrepreneurial culture is concerned with developing the individual’s capacity to produce, accumulate and expand. Considerable intelligence has been devoted to understanding how one becomes more productive, financially successful, influential and effective in pursuing one’s objectives.

Comparatively little attention is given to the individual pursuing them.

What is particularly striking is how often this entire field of activity is presented as human development. A person becomes financially successful and subsequently begins teaching others how to live, how to think and what constitutes a meaningful existence, as though his ability to accumulate wealth had necessarily provided him with a profound understanding of life.

Commercial intelligence is commercial intelligence. It does not automatically confer self-knowledge, emotional maturity or an understanding of human nature.

A person can spend thirty or forty years constructing an enterprise that bears remarkably little relationship to his actual nature. His responsibilities increase, his material circumstances improve, and he acquires greater influence over the world around him.

Yet the deep satisfaction he anticipated never quite arrives.

So he enlarges the undertaking. He enters another market, acquires another business or pursues another form of recognition. There is always something further to accomplish and consequently very little time to examine the absence of satisfaction accompanying what has already been accomplished.

The activity continues, and the emptiness continues with it.

His enterprise may provide employment, generate considerable wealth and produce things of genuine utility. It may acquire substantial value within the world while remaining remarkably devoid of meaning within his own existence.

My difficulty is not with capitalism, entrepreneurship or the accumulation of wealth. They are particular dimensions of human activity. What concerns me is their elevation into a purpose of human existence.

An economic system can function without requiring those participating in it to develop self-knowledge. My work cannot proceed from that separation.

When commercial accomplishment becomes a substitute for selfhood, the relationship between the creator and his creation has been inverted.

The man needs what he has created to tell him who he is.

Where Does the Energy Come From?

One of the things I have become particularly attentive to over the years is the source of the energy moving an individual.

Two people may appear equally industrious. Both may work long hours, possess remarkable discipline and accomplish substantial things. Yet what animates their respective activities may be fundamentally different.

In one individual, the impulse to act proceeds from something genuinely alive within him. There is inspiration, enthusiasm and a deep satisfaction in participating in the creation of something that has meaning for him. The undertaking may require considerable effort and perseverance, but there is a fundamental coherence between the individual and what he is doing.

In another individual, the work itself possesses very little capacity to animate him. Something else must continually be introduced. Anger, competition, greed, lust, attachment or the need to establish his importance provide the stimulation through which he mobilizes himself.

When the effects of one stimulus diminish, another must take its place.

He may appear to possess tremendous energy. What interests me is the manner in which that intensity is being sustained.

There is energy arising from inner alignment, and there is energy generated through friction.

A person can become extraordinarily productive through continually sustaining a state of inner conflict. The frustration of not being who he believes he ought to be, the anger associated with what he believes the world owes him, or the appetite for recognition can all become powerful instruments of mobilization.

But his organism participates in that arrangement.

During my years in the healing arts, I repeatedly encountered individuals whose highly productive lives coexisted with considerable physiological tension, anxiety, digestive disturbances and persistent difficulties sleeping. Such symptoms have numerous possible causes, but what became particularly apparent in certain individuals was the extent to which their continual need for stimulation was accompanied by an equally persistent inability to settle.

They could accomplish extraordinary things, yet they could scarcely sit with themselves.

The anger, ambition and agitation were not simply disturbances within their existence. They had become part of the machinery through which they sustained it. To surrender that machinery would mean confronting an emptiness they had spent considerable intelligence avoiding.

There is a profound difference between being animated by something genuinely alive within oneself and continually attempting to produce the sensation of being alive.

One proceeds from an intimate relationship with oneself. The other requires the continual maintenance of a particular distance from oneself.

That distance can become remarkably expensive when maintained over the course of an entire existence.

Giving Expression to What We Are

It is within this understanding that I approach business.

When an individual establishes a more intimate relationship with his nature, certain questions naturally arise. What does he perceive? What interests him? What qualities and capacities reside within him? What does he genuinely have to offer? And how can these things acquire a form through which they contribute something of value to the lives of others?

For some individuals, the answer may involve providing a personal service. For others, it may involve creating a product, establishing an institution or developing an enterprise through which hundreds of people eventually work together. It may have nothing to do with business at all.

Self-actualization does not prescribe a particular occupation or scale of accomplishment. Its significance lies in the relationship between the individual’s nature and the form through which that nature finds expression.

But discovering what one genuinely carries within oneself does not automatically establish the competence necessary to make it available to others.

A person may possess a beautiful sensitivity to the human body without having developed the knowledge or technical faculties necessary to become a competent practitioner. Another may possess considerable creative intelligence without understanding how to organize the circumstances through which his creations can become available to the world.

The outward movement requires its own education.

Just as the feminine movement requires the development of faculties through which one can investigate and understand oneself, the masculine movement requires the development of faculties through which one can give expression to what has been discovered.

One must learn how to communicate, establish relationships, organize resources, assume responsibilities and understand the environment within which one wishes to operate. If the undertaking is an enterprise, one must also understand its economic reality.

A beautiful intention does not exempt an individual from learning how to construct a viable business.

Developing these competencies is not separate from human development. It is part of it.

The construction of an enterprise can therefore become a remarkably rich territory of self-realization and self-actualization. Through the practical requirements of giving expression to what he carries within himself, the individual refines his understanding, extends his capacities and develops increasingly intelligent relationships with the world.

Something that initially existed within him gradually becomes available to others.

This is where the undertaking begins to bear fruit.

The Work of Integration

I have never found it particularly useful to establish rigid boundaries between the intimate and commercial dimensions of my work with individuals.

Someone may approach me because of difficulties within his relationships, his sexuality or his understanding of himself. Another may approach me because of a difficulty within an enterprise or an inability to bring a particular vision into existence.

Their circumstances differ, as may the direction in which our work initially proceeds. But the fundamental undertaking remains the same.

An individual struggling to give expression to himself may need to turn inward and discover something about his nature. Someone who has spent considerable time investigating himself may need to turn outward and develop the capacities necessary to participate more fully in life.

What needs to be established is the appropriate relationship between the two movements at that particular moment in the individual’s development.

This explains why my involvement in business has never represented a departure from my work in human development.

When I participate in the development of an enterprise, I am interested in its economic viability, its organizational intelligence and the possibilities available to it. I am interested in refining its direction, establishing greater coherence between its constituent parts and contributing to the creation of something genuinely valuable.

But I am equally interested in the individual through whom the enterprise acquires its direction.

What is he giving expression to? What is he discovering about himself through his work? What capacities are becoming available to him? And what is becoming available to others through the development of those capacities?

The enterprise and its creator develop through their relationship with one another.

When this relationship is harmonious, the work acquires a different quality. The individual no longer needs to continually compensate for the distance between himself and what he is doing. Inspiration is not something he must constantly manufacture through stimulation. It arises from his relationship with the undertaking itself.

There is considerable pleasure in this, and a deep satisfaction in recognizing something of one’s nature in what has acquired an existence beyond oneself.

It is this relationship between human development and creation that interests me.

The Fruit

The beauty of a tree is that it does not need to become something other than itself to contribute something of value to the world. Its contribution arises naturally through the development and expression of its own nature.

But that expression requires more than the mere possession of a nature. It requires growth, nourishment, development and an intelligent relationship with the environment in which it exists.

The discovery of what we are does not relieve us of the responsibility of developing it. Nor does the development of our faculties relieve us of the responsibility of understanding what we are giving expression to.

Throughout our lives, we turn inward to discover and outward to manifest. Neither movement reaches fulfilment in isolation. Together, they constitute the living process through which we come to know ourselves and make something of what we discover.

This is the relationship between self-realization and self-actualization.

It is the relationship between the seed and the tree, between our nature and what that nature makes available to the world.

The fruit is not a substitute for the seed, nor is it something foreign to it.

It is the fulfilment of something the seed has carried all along.