← All writings

The Universe of a Tension

admin writings

It was through my hands that I began to understand certain things about the human mind that years of intellectual investigation had not revealed to me.

Before studying osteopathy, I had explored the relationship between the mind and the body through medicine, nutrition, physical training and various traditional healing systems. I had also encountered it through my own difficulties. As a young man, I experienced physical problems for which conventional medical investigations had provided little resolution, and whose origins I eventually recognized as belonging to a much deeper state of anxiety.

The relationship between thought and physiology was therefore not an unfamiliar proposition. But there is an immense difference between knowing that a relationship exists and developing the faculties through which one can investigate it.

Osteopathy changed the nature of my inquiry. Through palpation, I began encountering the material expression of a person’s internal world. What initially presented itself as a physical restriction could reveal an emotional charge, a particular state of mind and, upon further investigation, an entire organization of thought. I was no longer simply examining a body. I was discovering the universe that held it in a particular condition.

Beyond the Anatomy

Palpation requires the development of a rather unusual faculty. One must learn to touch without imposing, to investigate without unnecessarily disturbing, and to distinguish what is being perceived from what one imagines one ought to perceive. As this faculty develops, what becomes available beneath the hands extends considerably beyond anatomy.

A restriction encountered in one region may belong to a constellation of tensions distributed throughout the organism, each participating in the maintenance of the others. What appears locally provides a point of entry into a much larger organization.

In my practice, I discovered that by remaining in contact with a tension, I could sometimes perceive something of the emotional condition associated with it. Going further, I could begin discerning the matrix of thought through which that condition was sustained. The tension had an architecture.

I began referring to this as the universe of a tension.

Within the osteopathic tradition in which I was trained, I explored these relationships through the primary respiratory mechanism, perceiving restrictions in the subtle movements of the cranial structures and following their relationships throughout the body. As a release occurred, these movements would sometimes settle into what osteopaths refer to as a still point. Subsequently, I would perceive changes throughout the organism: primary respiratory movement became more apparent, restrictions softened, and a quality of circulation and continuity returned.

Some of my most consequential discoveries came through receiving treatments myself from teachers whose faculties were considerably more developed than mine. Experiencing these phenomena within my own organism gave them a significance that no intellectual explanation could have provided. What I discovered under their hands profoundly influenced my practice of Yoga, meditation and my subsequent investigation of the human being.

But perhaps the most important discovery was not that thought could express itself through physiology. It was that the very tensions causing us to suffer could be performing functions we could not afford to lose.

What the Tension Is Holding

The conventional response to a tension is to attempt to release it. The person is uncomfortable, movement is restricted, and something appears to require correction. Before correcting it, however, one might consider asking a rather important question: what is it holding?

Imagine someone who has spent much of their existence carrying a considerable weight. Their movements have become restricted, their energy is increasingly consumed by the effort, and they complain incessantly about the burden. The obvious solution is to put it down. But suppose carrying that weight has become part of the very arrangement through which they remain upright.

Human beings carry histories, fears, emotional disturbances and conclusions about themselves. They develop personalities through which this material can be accommodated and elaborate narratives through which it acquires meaning. They can become remarkably romantic about what they are carrying. Their suffering acquires a certain nobility, and the circumstances responsible for it become part of their mythology.

Meanwhile, the organism continues paying the bill.

Beneath an impressive personality, a formidable intellect or an apparently well-organized existence, there may be very little genuine stability. Much of what we recognize as someone’s character may participate in the extraordinary effort through which they hold themselves together. The body is intimately involved in that undertaking.

When the roots are fragile, stability must be obtained elsewhere. The person develops structures of compensation, and eventually those structures become so familiar that they are mistaken for the person himself. He complains about the tension, suffers from its consequences and spends considerable resources attempting to relieve it. Yet he may be terrified of its disappearance.

One begins to appreciate the absurdity of telling someone in this condition to relax.

Relax into what?

If the tension participates in maintaining his sense of existence, its disappearance may be experienced not as liberation but as the beginning of a collapse. He has spent years developing the means to remain standing. He cannot simply abandon those means because someone has correctly identified their disadvantages.

A therapist who recognizes a restriction but fails to understand what it supports has understood only part of the situation. The body’s discomfort may be apparent; the intelligence of its organization may not be.

Providing Ground

One of the essential qualities of a healer is the capacity to provide stability. I do not mean reassurance, encouragement or the production of agreeable emotional states. I mean the ability to offer something that does not participate in the instability of the person in front of you.

The person arrives carrying an entire world. They have spent years maintaining its structure, defending its logic and sustaining the personality through which they inhabit it. Within the encounter, through touch, attention and the quality of one’s presence, different conditions can be established. The person can begin observing what they have been holding without immediately feeling threatened by the observation.

Recognition alone is not necessarily sufficient. A man may realize that the story he has been telling himself for twenty years is fundamentally inadequate. He may recognize the cost of maintaining a particular role and see the absurdity of certain aspects of his conduct. But dismantling a structure intellectually does not provide him with somewhere else to stand.

In osteopathy, I gradually came to appreciate the significance of providing this ground through my hands. Contact was not merely a technical operation upon the tissues. The absence of judgment, the steadiness of the person providing the contact and the stability communicated through it were integral to the encounter.

Sometimes, as a person became conscious of the state of mind associated with a tension, something previously inaccessible became visible. There was a realization and a certain digestion of what had been recognized. If the person was ready, and if sufficient stability was available, they could occasionally permit themselves to do something they had been unable to do for years.

They could put it down.

The healer has not taken the burden away. He has provided somewhere for it to be placed.

The Genuine Exhalation

There is a difference between instructing someone to exhale and witnessing a human being genuinely exhale. The first can be accomplished by following instructions. The second occurs when the necessity of holding begins to disappear.

I witnessed this numerous times during treatment. A person would become conscious of something they had been maintaining, perhaps for decades. Sometimes the realization was accompanied by considerable emotion; on other occasions, very little was said. The face would change, the body would settle, and the tension beneath my hands would undergo a transformation.

Nobody had instructed the person to relax. The relaxation emerged spontaneously because the person no longer experienced the same necessity to hold. What had previously required continuous effort could, for a moment, be relinquished without the anticipated collapse.

It was in this context that the still point acquired a much greater significance for me. Through my hands, I could perceive the quieting of movements that had previously been restricted or disturbed. But what interested me most was what this quietude made possible for the person.

The organism was no longer entirely occupied with maintaining a particular condition. There was an opportunity for integration, for something previously held in tension to find a different relationship with the whole. This required neither the suppression of what had become conscious nor the immediate construction of another narrative through which to accommodate it.

For a moment, the person could remain with what had been recognized.

Stillness, in this sense, was not merely the absence of activity. It was a condition from which a different activity could emerge.

The Restoration of Choice

We frequently confuse knowing that an alternative exists with possessing the freedom to pursue it.

A man knows perfectly well that his response to a particular situation is inappropriate. He understands the consequences of his conduct, has read extensively about his difficulties and may even be capable of providing excellent advice to someone experiencing something similar. Yet when the circumstances present themselves, he responds in precisely the same manner.

His knowledge has not liberated him from the conditions governing the response.

This is where a genuine release becomes particularly interesting. Through recognition, integration and the temporary cessation of the necessity to hold, an alternative that was previously inaccessible may become available. Before, the man could only go left. Now he can also go right.

The significance of this is easily underestimated. The alternative is no longer merely an intellectual proposition. It has become a possibility within his actual organization.

What he does with that possibility is another matter. He may return to the familiar configuration. Other aspects of his existence may continue requiring it. He may need further assistance or the development of faculties through which a different way of living can become established. A treatment can introduce a possibility that the person has yet to learn how to sustain.

A moment of release does not signify that the intelligence responsible for the previous condition has been fundamentally transformed. Nor does the disappearance of a symptom necessarily establish that its origins have been resolved. These are distinctions that deserve to be maintained, particularly in a profession where the immediate experience of relief can be mistaken for the completion of the work.

But where there was previously compulsion, there is now, to whatever degree the release has occurred, a possibility of freedom.

This is an important dimension of what I understand by healing. The power returned to the person is not the power to control everything that happens to them. It is the power to participate differently in what happens next.

Beyond the Hands

As my practice developed, I discovered that I no longer required my hands to enter certain dimensions of the universe I had initially encountered through palpation.

I could approach them through a conversation.

The manner in which someone spoke, the movements of their attention, the peculiarities of their reasoning and their reactions to a particular observation revealed something of the same organization I had learned to investigate through the body. Sometimes a look was sufficient. Sometimes it required an elaborate exchange, a dance of language through which we could approach something the person had been holding without unnecessarily disturbing them.

Words became another instrument of contact. There were occasions when much of the work took place through these exchanges, and when touch served primarily to ground what had occurred.

My hands had taught me to perceive. I was no longer confined to them.

Today, I may spend several hours with someone investigating an enterprise, a relationship or a consequential decision. We may discuss circumstances that appear to have absolutely nothing to do with osteopathy. And yet I recognize the movements.

A man is exhausting himself attempting to resolve a situation whose organization he has never properly understood. His thinking continually reinforces the necessity of his effort, and he has developed increasingly sophisticated explanations for why things must remain as they are.

Through our investigation, he begins to recognize relationships that previously escaped him. An entire situation acquires a different meaning. What he experienced as an obligation reveals itself as only one possibility arising from a particular understanding of his circumstances.

And he exhales.

I recognize this exhalation. I spent years encountering it beneath my hands.

No contract has been renegotiated. No enterprise has been reorganized. Nothing has necessarily changed in the material circumstances of his existence. But the man sitting in front of me is no longer relating to those circumstances through precisely the same intelligence.

There may be an enormous amount of work ahead. He may have to develop new faculties, reconsider fundamental decisions and reorganize considerable portions of his life. But something that was previously unavailable to him has become available.

He has a choice.

When I first began studying osteopathy, I was learning how to recognize restrictions in the human body. What I eventually discovered was something considerably more interesting: the human being’s capacity to remain imprisoned within a reality he is continually exerting himself to sustain.

And the extraordinary possibilities that emerge when he discovers that he no longer has to hold it together.