← All writings

The Hidden Objective

Mikhael K. Shah Essays

When someone speaks to me, I am listening to two things simultaneously. There is what they are telling me, and there is the intelligence producing what I am hearing. The first informs me of their situation. The second tells me where that situation is going.

Consider a website. What appears on the screen is the visible expression of an underlying architecture. Behind the images, words and functions is an arrangement of code, written according to a particular language and logic. Someone familiar with that architecture can anticipate what the system will produce without necessarily waiting for the result to appear on the screen.

I listen to human beings in much the same manner.

While someone describes their ambitions, relationships, difficulties and circumstances, I am examining the logic through which their reality is being constructed. Frequently, I can recognize that the programming directing their actions is incapable of producing the outcome they claim to desire.

It will produce something, certainly.

But what interests me is what it has been organized to produce.

When the logic of a system leads consistently toward a particular destination, why should I regard that destination as a failure?

Perhaps the programming is functioning perfectly. Perhaps we have simply misunderstood its objective.

The World We Must Prove Exists

We each inhabit a particular conception of reality. Throughout our lives, we develop conclusions about human nature, relationships, society, justice, love and our place within existence. Together, these conclusions constitute a world within which we recognize ourselves.

Our identity has meaning in relation to that world.

Consider a man who regards society as fundamentally hostile to people like himself. Others cannot appreciate his intelligence, his sincerity is rarely recognized, and the world generally rewards the wrong people.

He behaves in a particular manner. Eventually, people rebuke him, distance themselves from him or exclude him from their activities.

You see? I always knew.

What escapes his attention is the extent to which his own conception of the world has participated in producing the response he now receives from it. His expectations, interpretations and defensiveness enter the relationship before the other person has had much opportunity to reveal themselves.

The resulting rejection possesses extraordinary value. It preserves the integrity of his worldview.

And in preserving that worldview, it preserves him.

But something else occurs. The rejection awakens him. Anger rises, his imagination becomes active, and an enormous quantity of energy suddenly becomes available. He must prove himself, demonstrate his superiority or accomplish something sufficiently impressive to establish that the world was mistaken about him.

For a man accustomed to deriving his vitality from such experiences, being rejected can be remarkably stimulating.

Now imagine depriving him of his adversaries.

Where would he obtain his fuel? What would become of the extraordinary movement they continually awaken within him? Who would he be in a world that no longer required him to fight?

The man protests against the very circumstances that animate his existence.

I am not suggesting that every misfortune is secretly desired, or that we exercise control over everything that happens to us. I am concerned here with the circumstances we actively participate in creating and repeatedly reproduce through a recognizable structure of thought.

An entire existence can develop around proving something its author has never seriously investigated.

The Romanticization of Appetite

I use the expression hidden objective, although there is often very little that is particularly hidden about it. What someone repeatedly organizes their existence to produce becomes rather apparent once we stop granting so much authority to their explanations.

Human beings possess a remarkable talent for romanticizing their appetites.

Consider love.

A man may aspire to a profound relationship with a woman while possessing only a rudimentary comprehension of what such a relationship involves. Much of what he recognizes as love may have been established through previous experiences of emotional intensity. Anticipation, uncertainty, jealousy, reconciliation, the fear of loss and the relief of being desired produce powerful sensations within the organism.

He learns to associate these sensations with love and becomes increasingly proficient at creating the conditions through which they arise. The tension must be produced before the release can be experienced. Something must be threatened so that its recovery acquires the desired intensity.

He has become involved in the production of his own chemistry. The relationship provides the environment.

Give the arrangement a sufficiently beautiful narrative and he may never recognize the nature of his appetite. He speaks of passion, destiny, extraordinary connections and the peculiar difficulties that seem to accompany profound love.

Meanwhile, he is getting high.

Two people can spend years becoming exceptionally proficient at stimulating one another without ever developing much understanding of love.

And yet, beneath all of this, the aspiration toward a profound relationship may be entirely genuine.

A human being can aspire to something considerably greater than their present intelligence permits them to create. Therein lies an extraordinary difficulty. Our conception of what we desire is largely derived from experiences we have already had. We attempt to reach something we do not yet know through the means available to us within the world we already know.

The vehicle is inadequate to the destination.

For as long as that vehicle delivers a sufficiently satisfying experience, however, the deeper aspiration can remain dormant. The man has something to consume and a rather convincing narrative through which to justify consuming it.

Why investigate further?

The Intelligence of Contraction

One of the people with whom I work possesses considerable technical knowledge. Whenever a new project presents itself, however, I observe a familiar movement in his thinking.

He begins by making the world smaller.

A commercial undertaking involves numerous relationships: the nature of the industry, the organization of the client’s business, the people involved, the actual commercial objective and the various means through which that objective might be realized.

Rather than examining the whole, he selects a narrow collection of elements and becomes intensely occupied with them. He accumulates information, investigates increasingly minute details and develops elaborate solutions to problems whose significance has yet to be established.

When I begin expanding his field of investigation, he becomes uncomfortable. Suddenly, there are relationships he has not considered, questions he cannot answer and possibilities for which his considerable technical knowledge provides inadequate preparation.

His immediate inclination is to return to the details.

Within the territory he has established, he feels competent. He possesses information, knows what to do and experiences a sense of control.

Outside that territory, he encounters his ignorance.

The contraction of his perspective serves a function. It provides security, while the intensity of his activity within that confined space generates a familiar internal state. The commercial undertaking is merely one environment in which this occurs. I recognize the same movement in other areas of his existence.

The subjects change; the programming does not.

He can spend enormous quantities of energy trying to succeed while continually reproducing the conditions that limit his possibilities of success.

There is nothing particularly mysterious about this once we recognize what the process provides him. He is obtaining something from it. But what he obtains is not necessarily what the project requires.

Giving him another thousand pages of information might simply provide him with more material through which to perpetuate the problem. He needs to learn to think on a different scale.

When we examine the undertaking from a greater perspective, the relationships between its different elements begin to emerge. He recognizes which problems deserve his attention and which were generated by his incomplete conception of the project. He sees what he needs to learn, where his capabilities are insufficient and where another person’s intelligence could contribute something of genuine value.

The agitation subsides.

Notice what has just occurred. No additional resources have been acquired. No technical problem has been resolved. The external circumstances remain essentially the same. Yet his physiological state has changed, and an entirely different course of action has become available to him.

What has changed is his relationship with reality.

There is a correspondence between the clarity of his perception, the condition of his nervous system and the possibilities he can recognize. What appeared to require extraordinary effort may now require considerably more learning and considerably less activity.

I am not particularly interested in making someone more efficient within a corridor that should never have been so narrow.

The First Degree of Harmony

When someone begins recognizing the intelligence behind their own conduct, there is no immediate necessity to change it.

A man may finally acknowledge that rejection stimulates him, that conflict provides him with vitality, or that the frustration surrounding his enterprise serves a purpose he has never been willing to admit.

There is already a degree of harmony in this recognition.

He no longer needs to maintain a fictional account of his relationship with what he has created. He can acknowledge that he is obtaining something he desires, even if it bears little resemblance to what he has been telling himself.

And perhaps, for the moment, he is perfectly content to continue.

There is little intelligence in persuading him to pretend otherwise.

But sometimes the appetite begins to exhaust itself.

The Exhaustion of a World

We may eventually reach a point at which the experiences we have spent years reproducing no longer provide the same satisfaction.

This does not necessarily bring about a change of direction.

The man who can no longer obtain his familiar high may become intensely occupied with recovering it. The frustration of not obtaining it generates another kind of stimulation. He increases the intensity, changes the circumstances or searches for increasingly sophisticated alternatives to what he previously consumed.

He believes he is looking for something new.

But the entire search may still belong to the same universe.

The failure of the drug can itself become another drug.

Even the pursuit of transformation can be recruited into this process. The man becomes fascinated by his difficulties, continually investigates himself, acquires new explanations and develops an increasingly sophisticated vocabulary through which to describe an existence that remains fundamentally unchanged.

He has discovered another way to occupy himself within the same world.

Occasionally, however, something more consequential occurs. Not merely the exhaustion of a particular experience, but the exhaustion of the entire universe of experiences available through an existing conception of reality.

The alternatives no longer possess much appeal. Greater intensity changes very little. Even the search for another source of satisfaction begins to lose its significance.

The man finds himself confronted with an extraordinarily sobering realization.

This does not work.

And for perhaps the first time, he is not particularly interested in making it work.

This is not disappointment. Disappointment may provide the impetus for another attempt. What I am describing is the exhaustion of the very framework within which all those attempts have taken place.

Here we encounter one of the more interesting possibilities of disharmony. The difficulties we spend our lives attempting to eliminate can occasionally bring us to a threshold we would never otherwise have encountered.

At that threshold, a deeper aspiration, long obscured by the continual movement of our appetites, may awaken.

We begin to suspect that what we have spent our lives consuming is not what we fundamentally wanted to experience.

Such moments are considerably rarer than the industry devoted to human transformation might have us believe.

The Upgrade

Someone arriving at this threshold requires something beyond another strategy for obtaining what they want.

They require what I sometimes refer to as an upgrade.

By this, I do not mean the acquisition of additional information within an existing framework. I mean an expansion of the framework itself.

Return to the man who aspires to a profound relationship.

Teaching him to communicate more effectively, regulate his emotions or behave more agreeably toward a woman may be useful, but these developments do not necessarily alter his fundamental conception of what a relationship is.

We must expand his comprehension of human nature, of man and woman, of the movement of Life and of what can actually be created through their association.

As this greater territory becomes visible, he begins to see himself differently. He discovers faculties he has yet to develop, limitations he previously mistook for natural characteristics and possibilities that his earlier conception of existence could not accommodate.

The direction of this movement is fundamental.

We are not attempting to persuade the man to think differently about himself. We are expanding his understanding of the reality within which he exists.

A different understanding of himself emerges in relation to that greater reality.

This can be extremely demanding. Alongside the discovery of new possibilities comes the discovery of one’s ignorance. What appeared relatively simple may reveal extraordinary complexity. Faculties one assumed one possessed may require years of cultivation.

It is frequently here that assistance becomes necessary. Someone with a greater perspective can introduce relationships and principles that the man could not discover through the continued operation of his existing programming.

Whether this expanded perception subsequently becomes an operative intelligence, integrated within his nervous system and stabilized through his participation in the material world, is another undertaking altogether.

Recognition is not transformation.

Seeing the territory and developing the faculties through which one can inhabit it are two very different accomplishments.

The Appearance of Success

It would be a mistake to assume that this investigation concerns only those who fail to accomplish their stated objectives.

A man may establish an enterprise of extraordinary commercial significance, accumulate billions and realize almost everything he once imagined.

The accomplishment is undeniable.

But has he obtained what he was fundamentally seeking through it?

Perhaps the enterprise has been a magnificent expression of his nature, continually opening new territories of existence. Or perhaps he has spent thirty years developing an extraordinary vehicle in pursuit of something that the vehicle was never capable of delivering.

His financial statements cannot tell us.

A man can fail to build the enterprise he wants and successfully preserve the world he knows. Another can build the greatest enterprise imaginable and remain profoundly distant from what he originally sought.

The distinction between these two men may be considerably smaller than their respective accomplishments suggest.

Both have exercised intelligence. Both have brought something into existence. Both may have arrived precisely where their programming was organized to take them.

This is why, before becoming particularly interested in helping someone succeed, I prefer to establish what their intelligence is already succeeding at.

The answer is not always flattering.

But it may be the beginning of an entirely different life.